Charleston White DEFENDS Karmelo Anthony, Says He’s NOT GUILTY After Speaking with Karmelo’s Father: The Shocking Twist Dividing Texas

A Tragedy Shakes Texas—and a New Voice Enters the Arena

Just weeks ago, the tragic sta::bbing of Austin Metcalf at a high school track meet in Frisco, Texas, seemed like a cut-and-dried case. Two teens. One d3adly confrontation. A community in uproar, and a young man—Karmelo Anthony—facing the full weight of a first-degree murder charge. But in a twist nobody saw coming, controversial activist and internet firebrand Charleston White has thrown his support behind Karmelo, claiming the teenager is “not guilty” after private conversations with Karmelo’s father. Now, the narrative is shifting fast—and everyone’s got an opinion.

Charleston White Flips the Script: From Outrage to Apology

Charleston White is no stranger to controversy. He’s made a career out of saying the unsayable, and in the days after the sta::bbing, he was right there with the chorus: “Karmelo’s going to jail. He brought a kn!fe to school. There’s no self-defense here.” But then, something changed. White met with Karmelo’s father. He listened. He looked at the facts. And suddenly, the man who’d been calling for jail time was singing a different tune.

“I was all the way wrong about that kid,” White admitted in a raw, unfiltered video. “He didn’t even know those two white boys. He wasn’t looking for trouble. He was just in the wrong place at the wrong time.”

The Racial Firestorm: Is This About Justice—or Just Race?

As the story exploded online, social media split into warring tribes. One side saw a black teenager being railroaded by a mostly white justice system; the other saw a violent act that demanded punishment. Charleston White, never one to shy away from the race card, waded in deep. At first, he claimed Austin Metcalf and his friends were “big, violent, aggressive white boys” who cornered Karmelo. He even called out the Metcalf family, painting them as absentee and abusive—fuel for an already raging fire.

But here’s the thing: the more White talked, the more the story slipped away from the facts. The Metcalf boys, he claimed, were notorious bullies. Their father, he said, was never around. But even White’s own followers were left scratching their heads—was this really about race, or just two teenagers making catastrophic mistakes?

The Kn!fe: Weapon or Boy Scout Tool?

No detail has been more hotly debated than the kn!fe itself. Prosecutors say Karmelo brought a d3adly weapon to a school event—a premeditated act. But White, after talking with Karmelo’s family, insists it was just a multi-tool, the kind “most white people give their elementary kids.” Was it a lethal blade, or a harmless gadget? The truth, as always, seems to be somewhere in the messy middle. But the stakes couldn’t be higher: if the court believes Karmelo was armed for a fight, the charge sticks. If not, everything changes.

The Law in Texas: A High Bar for Conviction

Texas is tough on crime, but even here, trying a 17-year-old as an adult for first-degree murder isn’t easy. Prosecutors need proof of premeditation—evidence that Karmelo planned to k!ll, not just defend himself. That’s a high bar, and with video evidence reportedly showing Austin Metcalf making the first physical move, the self-defense argument is gaining traction.

Charleston White is betting big on this. “He’s going to beat these charges,” White declared, urging the public to see past the headlines and look at the facts. But not everyone’s convinced. Critics say White is cherry-picking details, ignoring the pain of the Metcalf family, and stirring up racial resentment for clicks and clout.

The Community Reacts: Fear, Anger, and a Search for Truth

Meanwhile, the families at the heart of this tragedy are living a nightmare. Karmelo’s family has reportedly been forced to move multiple times amid threats and harassment. The Metcalfs are left mourning a son who di3d in his twin brother’s arms. Online, the debate rages on: Was Karmelo a victim of bullying and racial profiling, or a dangerous teen who made a fatal choice?

Charleston White’s voice, loud as ever, is only making things more chaotic. His wild swings—from condemnation to defense, from calling for jail time to demanding justice for Karmelo—mirror the confusion and pain gripping the community.

Final Word: No Easy Answers, Only Broken Lives

At the end of the day, this is a story with no real winners. A promising young man is d3ad. Another faces years behind bars. Two families are shattered, and an entire town is left asking how things could have gone so wrong, so fast. Charleston White may have changed his mind, but the facts—and the heartbreak—remain.

As the trial looms, one thing is certain: the truth will have to fight its way through a storm of rumor, rage, and raw emotion. And in the court of public opinion, the verdict is still very much up for grabs.